If there were silver linings last year, one of them may have been a broader view and awareness of diversity and inclusion issues in the workplace. As the employers of nearly 16 million temporary and contract workers each year, staffing companies with reliable and relevant employee-focused data will be more competitive and successful in the short term and the long run.
Staffing companies, however, also must engage, retain, and develop their own corporate employees to grow and succeed. Recently, ASA research partner ClearlyRated released new industry-specific data that can help staffing companies take a fresh look at their corporate practices when it comes to diversity, inclusion, and equity.
Culled from interviews across more than 50 staffing companies, the data show strengths and weaknesses. In terms of gender, the industry is doing a good job of bringing in women—but when it comes to moving them up, the numbers are not nearly as strong.
“We are getting good representation. As an industry we hire more women than men,” says ClearlyRated chief executive officer Eric Gregg. “But as you look at the additional levels of leadership and management they might attain, you see those numbers drop off dramatically.”
In terms of ethnicity, there are issues around intake and retention. “We don’t actually hire a lot of Black or Hispanic people: There is a top-of-the-funnel problem, and then on top of that we aren’t able to retain them long enough to give them opportunities within leadership and management,” Gregg says.
Here’s an overview of the findings. (To view an on-demand webinar on this topic, “Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion in the Staffing Industry: Insights From Industry Leaders and Data From the Field,” go to americanstaffing.net/webinars.)
What the Numbers Show
In terms of race and ethnicity, representation in staffing lags behind the general population. Hispanics account for 8% of corporate staffing employees, versus 17.3% of the population at large. Black workers make up 4.8% of corporate staffing employees versus 12.3% of the overall. Asians fare slightly better, making up 9.2% within staffing as compared to 6.3% of the general population.
Women, meanwhile, are statisically overrepresented in the industry: They make up 58.1% of the staffing corporate workforce versus 47% of the general population. The numbers flip for men, who account for 40.2% within staffing and 53% of the overall.
Other figures worth noting: The LGBTA+ community accounts for 3.9% of staffing personnel, veterans account for 1.6%, and single parents make up 6.9%.
As Gregg notes, many of the stronger diversity numbers taper off as researchers explore the upper echelons of staffing. Those who identify as Black or Hispanic make up 2.7% of staffing executives, 5.6% of directors, 16.5% of branch managers, and 5.5.% of account managers. Women represent 72.6% of support staff and account for just 27% of executives. They make up more than 48.3% of the director ranks, 43.7% of branch managers, and 65.1% of account managers.
In the context of diversity and inclusion, the researchers also asked staffing company employees how they feel about the industry. Overall, they classed just 10.6% as detractors and 67% as promoters. Views among women aligned almost exactly with those figures, while Black workers took a slightly less positive view, with 13% detractors and 62% promoters.
What the Data Mean
While the data reveal the lay of the land among staffing firms, it’s useful to dig in deeper to understand the implications of this research.
“We have to ask the next question, which is: Why?” Gregg notes. Why isn’t staffing as a whole doing a better job of hiring for diversity? Why aren’t women and minorities making it into positions of leadership in larger numbers?
Research shows that women and minorities feel they are less likely to have the same opportunities for advancement. Perception matters: Just 7.1% of men versus 13.4% of Black workers are detractors. It’s reasonable to posit that lack of opportunity for advancement feeds those negative perceptions. There’s a gap in perception around pay as well.
Some 30% of women and 49% of Black workers don’t feel they are paid fairly compared to others who do similar work, versus 26% of men and 21% of White employees who hold such views. Some of those perceptions are grounded in fact. “Say you hire a diverse crew,” Gregg explains. “Fast forward two years and that cohort will have lost women and it will have lost people of color. When you look to see who is ready to be promoted, you see a lot of white and a lot of male.”
The “why” of all this is complex. There may be unconscious bias, or perhaps business structures lean toward male advancement. Staffing firms, for example, may not offer the kind of flexibility that gives a single mother the chance to do her best work. Each firm will likely need to explore its own circumstance in order to get to causation.
In the meantime, though, there are changes that can be made across the board in terms of greater diversity and inclusion throughout the echelons. “We have to focus on making people feel that this is a place for them and a place where they can make a career,” Gregg asserts.
—Eric Gregg, ClearlyRated
For many leaders—especially the white males who may not share a lived experience with women and minority employees—this means getting out of your personal headspace. “If you are a leader, you cannot intuit this on your own. You have to measure it, and you have to ask people the right questions: Do they feel included? Do they feel like there is fairness in compensation?” Gregg says. “And if they tell you that you are behind, then you have to look at what you can do to change that. That means we have to be OK with being vulnerable as leaders. We have to open ourselves up to actually learning.”
Those looking for a simple, practical first step can try “blind hiring.” For a given applicant pool, strip away all the identifying markers—anything in the application that might give a clue as to gender, race, or ethnicity. Redact those details and make your first assessment based on more objective criteria. By eliminating unconscious bias early in the process, “you end up with a much more diverse group of candidates who make it to the interview round,” Gregg says.
Blind hiring doesn’t address the disparity in advancement opportunity, however. That will require a deeper dive into the specific people and processes that drive each staffing firm. But it can be a good place to start, leveling the playing field and bringing a more diverse workforce through the front door.
Adam Stone, a freelance writer based in Annapolis, MD, is a regular contributor to Staffing Success. Send feedback on this article to success@americanstaffing.net. Engage with ASA on social media—go to americanstaffing.net/social.
Staffing Success Magazine - January–February 2021
Sorry, the content you’ve selected is for members only. Maybe it’s time to join! Or if you’re already a member, please log in. Join today to enjoy all the benefits of ASA membership. Strategic business intelligence Legal help and advocacy Learning and professional development ASA publications Exclusive industry data Community and networking And more! Learn… More ›
The American Staffing Association and U.S. Department of Labor’s Office of Disability Employment Policy formally renewed an alliance to focus on advancing the employment of people with disabilities. The signing of the alliance took place during the ASA Staffing Law Conference at the Grand Hyatt in Washington, DC. Since first signing an alliance in 2020,… More ›
As the chief executive officer of a company that links staffing agencies to job seekers nationwide, Eric Gregg knew the industry needed to be more focused on diversity, equity, and inclusion. But the pandemic and subsequent protests over racial and social justice, combined with the timely prodding of a new staff member, prompted Gregg and… More ›
The impact of the persisting pandemic has been felt far and wide, most notably relative to the labor market and the resulting strain on the economy. While there are no crystal balls and forecasts are changing constantly based on pandemic “what if” scenarios, growth-focused company leaders cannot afford to pause planning for business recovery, expansion,… More ›
To help your company plan for a successful 2021 and beyond in the current environment, ASA commissioned ClearlyRated (a third-party research firm) to conduct a survey gathering potential employee perceptions and experiences in order to gain a better understanding of how staffing agencies can navigate the new employment realities of the coronavirus pandemic. While a… More ›
Like the U.S. economy, the staffing industry has been rocked to its core by Covid-19. In these unprecedented times, many staffing companies have faced extraordinary demands for workers in support of health care, manufacturing, and other essential needs. ASA stepped in early with actionable insights for its member staffing companies, creating a microsite with information… More ›
The longer-than-anticipated presence of Covid-19 has severely affected the livelihood and significantly elevated levels of stress for millions in the U.S., but disproportionately it would seem, based on one’s demographics. Concerns Differ by Race/Ethnicity People of color are much more likely to be concerned about a variety of work-related issues: Hispanic/Latino and Black/African-American individuals are… More ›
Sorry, the content you’ve selected is for members only. Maybe it’s time to join! Or if you’re already a member, please log in. Join today to get full access to Staffing Success and all ASA publications. ASA brings members a steady flow of valuable information through a suite of publications. Staffing Success magazine, our award-winning flagship… More ›
The Form I-9 is a complicated two-page document that is accompanied by a 65-page handbook explaining how to complete it. There are many facets of I-9 completion that are unique to staffing firms. E-Verify is an Internet-based system maintained by U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services that allows businesses to verify the work eligibility of employees. The American Staffing Association offers this document to address the Form I-9 and E-Verify issues that staffing firms face most frequently. More ›
Sorry, the content you’ve selected is for members only. Maybe it’s time to join! Or if you’re already a member, please log in. Join today to get full access to Staffing Success and all ASA publications. ASA brings members a steady flow of valuable information through a suite of publications. Staffing Success magazine, our award-winning flagship… More ›